Tuesday, November 28, 2023
It's a new week again! It's coming to the end of this semester and we are going to have a long break! Let's keep going!
Experiences and feelings this week
This week is quite busy. We did not have the tutorial because of our micro-teaching
demo in the next week so we only had one lecture. During the lecture, Dr. Lina as usual linked previous knowledge to this lesson. Then, she talked about the criteria and requirements of assignments such as the time length of individual presentations, zoom recording, and others, which cleared all of my questions about the assignments, and I am delighted because I know what I need to do with clear instructions. After that, Dr. Lina introduced the learning objectives based on the SMART model (specific, measurable, assignable, realistic, and time-related) and Bloom's taxonomy with some detailed examples. In addition, we also learned the criteria of good learning objectives and their importance with examples as well. Everything was clear to me and I was excited because I had difficulties in writing good learning objectives before. However, after this lecture, I no longer needed to worry about thisπ. The most important thing is that when we design learning objectives, we need to follow the bloom's taxonomy. In the end, We were given a research paper to start the guided reading activity. During this activity, we learned the significance of questioning, some techniques of questioning, types of questions, strategies for formulating questions (Socratic method questioning, question circles, and student-generated questions), and principles of questions. It was quite informative for me and I had never known its importance before. At first, I did not understand why we needed to learn something simple or basic. Nevertheless, through this lecture, especially for Dr. Lina's detailed explanations of the importance and effectiveness of using questions as an effective teaching tool, I knew the importance of questions particularly when it comes to higher-order questions and simple questions. It made me awfully impressed and my interest was piqued. I could not wait to see how to make higher-order questions. Lastly, every group was called to write one question according to the Question Circles Method. Our group had a hot discussion of the question and finally, Nicholas wrote the question for our group (Thank god! I was also nominated at that time but we had not prepared well. Thanks Nicholasπ ).
demo in the next week so we only had one lecture. During the lecture, Dr. Lina as usual linked previous knowledge to this lesson. Then, she talked about the criteria and requirements of assignments such as the time length of individual presentations, zoom recording, and others, which cleared all of my questions about the assignments, and I am delighted because I know what I need to do with clear instructions. After that, Dr. Lina introduced the learning objectives based on the SMART model (specific, measurable, assignable, realistic, and time-related) and Bloom's taxonomy with some detailed examples. In addition, we also learned the criteria of good learning objectives and their importance with examples as well. Everything was clear to me and I was excited because I had difficulties in writing good learning objectives before. However, after this lecture, I no longer needed to worry about thisπ. The most important thing is that when we design learning objectives, we need to follow the bloom's taxonomy. In the end, We were given a research paper to start the guided reading activity. During this activity, we learned the significance of questioning, some techniques of questioning, types of questions, strategies for formulating questions (Socratic method questioning, question circles, and student-generated questions), and principles of questions. It was quite informative for me and I had never known its importance before. At first, I did not understand why we needed to learn something simple or basic. Nevertheless, through this lecture, especially for Dr. Lina's detailed explanations of the importance and effectiveness of using questions as an effective teaching tool, I knew the importance of questions particularly when it comes to higher-order questions and simple questions. It made me awfully impressed and my interest was piqued. I could not wait to see how to make higher-order questions. Lastly, every group was called to write one question according to the Question Circles Method. Our group had a hot discussion of the question and finally, Nicholas wrote the question for our group (Thank god! I was also nominated at that time but we had not prepared well. Thanks Nicholasπ ).
Previous experience in writing learning objectives and asking questions
Previously I wrote numerous learning objectives based on the ABCD model (Audience, Behavior, Condition, and degree) instead of utilizing the SMART model as well as Bloom's taxonomy to write them. Consequently, I was new to writing learning objectives based on the SMART model and Bloom's taxonomy. Especially, when it comes to the measurable learning objectives and the utilization of Bloom's taxonomy. Actually, I learned this SMART method when commenting on Lulu's blog of my group in week 1 (In some cases, I was not a novice because I learned it and delved into it before.ππ) To make learning objectives measurable, we needed to use 'by' to indicate what actions students will take to achieve learning objectives. We also needed to utilize Bloom's taxonomy when designing learning objectives, to make learning objectives present the progression of cognitive levels of students in learning. They were the most impressive parts of the lecture and I had never realized them even though I had written numerous learning objectives before. What's more, this lecture reminded me of my previous experiences in teaching. Previously, I only asked some questions that were low-level questions recall questions or simple questions such as who, what, and others. These questions only focus on the surface or comprehension of knowledge without enhancing their higher order of thinking skills and mastering of subject content in the real world. Through the reflection of previous experiences and this lecture, I knew its importance for teachers, especially for us as pre-service teachers. In addition, through this lecture, several theories were learned and reminded.
Learning objectives based on SMART
Presently, the SMART model in management is widely acknowledged as the established standard for formulating effective and measurable goals as well as objectives in various aspects such as education(Pearson, 2012). As a consequence, It is imperative to utilize the SMART model when designing learning objectives for students. Here are some examples and explanations of how to create learning objectives according to the SMART model.
The S presents specific which means that our learning objectives should be clear and specific. To make it specific, we could ask ourselves five 'W' including (what, which, who, where, why).
The M means measurable. We should set learning objectives that can be tracked so that we can track the progress and stay motivated. We could ask ourselves those questions (how much? How many? How can I know when it is accomplished?)
The A means attainable/achievable. It means that the goal should be attainable and realistic (How can I accomplish the goal).
The R means Relevant. We also need to ensure the learning objectives are relevant and align with other learning objectives.
The T means time-bond. Our learning objectives should have a deadline.
Here are some examples.
1. By the end of this class (Time-bond), Students will be able to verbally explain (specific) the concept of the ecosystem (achievable and realistic) by answering questions in the discussion (measurable).
2. By the end of this class (Time-bond), Students will be able to identify different ecosystems by illustrating specific ecosystems of their countries in the discussion.
These two examples are relevant to our topic and they are gradually progressing as well.
Another example for us when writing our personal goals.
Specific: I will publish four 1,500-word blog posts on my blog each month.
Measurable: I will have fifty-two blog posts on my blog by the end of the year.
Achievable: I have already started a blog and will shift my focus to writing 1,500 words on my blog each week.
Relevant: I have always wanted to increase traffic to my blog. This will allow me to build my brand and eventually make money blogging.
Time-bound: I will start writing next week and have fifty-two blog posts one year from today.
The whole sentence: Starting next week, I will post a 1,500-word article on my blog each week for a year, culminating in fifty-two blog posts and increased traffic to my site (I can not finish this ππ)
After breaking them down, we will find it easy to write the goals for us right?
After breaking them down, we will find it easy to write the goals for us right?
After delving into the SMART method, I also found numerous effectiveness of it. According to the research conducted by Aghera et al. (2018), learning objectives based on the SMART model will result in more educational actions that are taken and learning outcomes. In addition, Bjerke & Renger (2016) demonstrated the effectiveness associated with the integration of the SMART method such as the enhancement of program capacity, and the ability to autonomously monitor progress (maybe it can also improve the metacognition development) and outcome objectives. Most importantly, goals without challenges that may lead to suboptimal performance were exhibited. Consequently, we should make full use of the SMART method to create learning objectives to enhance students' overall development.
Bloom's Taxonomy and Bloom's Taxonomy verbs
It is imperative to utilize Bloom's taxonomy when designing learning objectives. Bloom's taxonomy discerns between various levels of cognitive skills and emphasizes learning objectives that need higher orders of cognitive proficiency, which consequently fosters profound learning and the transference of knowledge as well as skills across diverse tasks and contexts (Adams, 2015). Additionally, the application of Bloom's taxonomy prompts teachers to formulate learning objectives in behavioral terms, necessitating contemplation of the demonstrable capabilities acquired by students through instruction and learning objectives written with action verbs inherently signals the best approach for assessing the imparted skills as well as knowledge. Moreover, According to Athanassious et al. (2003), the application of Bloom's taxonomy as a learning tool (metacognitive framework) enhanced students' higher-order thinking skills as well as students' achievements. The most important part is to utilize Bloom's action verbs when designing learning objects in a progressive way to enhance students' higher order of thinking skills and overall development.
Here is a list of action verbs that we can follow when designing learning objectives.
Guided reading
During the lecture, we had an activity called guided reading. Guided reading has been recognized widely as an effective instructional approach in education especially for literacy education. In this activity, Dr. Lina utilized it by asking questions, giving hints, and demonstrating to encourage strategic behaviors, which enhances comprehension, critical thinking, and reading ability (Young, 2018). Furthermore, one study has demonstrated its effectiveness such as improving reading skills, decoding, and fluency (Fountas & Pinnell, 1996). Guided reading also fosters critical thinking skills as students engage in discussions, analyze texts, and make connections, which is what we did in the lecture (in the lecture, we discussed what kinds of questions, and how to incorporate three components of question circles to create one question that can activate higher order of thinking skills) and it contributes to deeper comprehension as well as higher-order thinking skills. It also reminded me of constructivism because we are proactive learners who construct our own comprehension through interactions with others. According to Freeman et al. (2014), active learners exhibited higher academic achievements and lower failure rates compared with others. In addition, after guided reading, each group was required to write one question according to the question circle. It reminded me of the concrete experiences in Kolb's learning cycle and experimental learning theory, which allows us to practice what we have learned in the lecture and have more experiences of practice to improve the master of knowledge. After that, we could analyze our experience in our blogs by using the 5Rs (the effectiveness of Kolb's learning cycle in week 5ππ).Questioning
In the end, questioning in teaching and learning sessions is one of the most important aspects of mastering knowledge. To improve the ability to question, questioning techniques are the most important parts that need to be seriously taken into account. According to Shanmugavelu et al. (2020), questioning significantly enhances students' engagement in the teaching and learning process and fosters students' mastery of Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS). Through questioning, teachers will be able to explain important content to students to help them form consolidated comprehension as well as develop their thinking to a higher level. It is common for teachers in the classroom to frequently employ questions of lower-order or recall-type questions. The excessive reliance on such questioning poses a hindrance to endeavors aimed at cultivating advanced, HOTS among students. Therefore, we should utilize the question circle when designing questions. Question circles is a strategy of questions designed to guide students progressively from surface-level responses toward more profound and extensive discussions pertaining to the subject matter (Tofade et al., 2013). It has three components in total including Text, Reader, and World. Through the utilization of question circles, students' personal responses are received, which leads students to have deeper insights into the content subject and the world as well as HOSTs are enhanced as well. To form good questions, the five principles also need to be followed including phrasing and clarity, psychological safety, sequencing and balance, wait time, and pimping questions. Therefore, questioning needs to be given greater attention by educators to produce students who can
compete globally
Conclusion
To sum up, one takeaway message from this lesson is I will employ more meaningful questions no matter what in teaching in the future or in my personal life to practice HOSTs of my students and mine. It really helps me to gain a comprehensive insight into subjects, things, news, and all things around me. It also makes me more critical when seeing an article and helps me to make better decisions because I can ask more insightful questions to weigh the advantages and disadvantages. What's more, questioning is one of the most powerful teaching tools, and I will make full use of it when teaching in the future to help cultivate students to be more critical, moral, and advanced with competence to compete in the changing world. In addition, as a future teacher, I will incorporate the SMART model and Bloom's taxonomy in writing learning objectives to better track students' progress and give immediate feedback to better help their growth.
Reference List:
Aghera, A., Emery, M., Bounds, R., Bush, C., Stansfield, R. B., Gillet, B., & Santen, S. A. (2018). A Randomized Trial of SMART Goad Enhanced Debriefing after Simulation to Promote Educational Actions. The Western Journal of Emergency Medicine, 19(1), 112-120.
Adams, N. E. (2015). Bloom's taxonomy of cognitive learning objectives. Journal of the Medical Library Association, 103(3), 152-153.
Athanassiou, N., McNett, J., & Harvey, C. (2003). Critical Thinking in the Management Classroom: Bloom's Taxonomy as a Learning Tool. Organizational Behavior Teaching Review, 27(5), 533-555.
Bjerke, M. B., & Renger, R. (2016). Being smart about writing SMART objectives. Evaluation and Program Planning, 61, 125-127.
Founta, I. C., & Pinnell, G. S. (1996). Guided Reading: Good First Teaching for All Children. Heinemann.
Freeman, S., Eddy, S. L., McDonough, M., Smith, M. K., Okoroafor, N., Jordt, H., & Weneroth, M. P. (2014). Active learning increases student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 111(23), 8410-8415.
Pearson, E. S. (2012). Goal setting as a health behavior change strategy in overweight and obese adults: A systematic literature review examining intervention components. Patient Education and Counseling, 87,(1), 32-42.
Shanmugavelu, G., Ariffin, K., Vadivelu, M., Mahayudin, Z., & Sundaram, M. A. R. K. (2020). Questioning Techniques and Teachers' Role in the Classroom. International Journal of Education, 8(4), 45-49.
Tofade, T., Elsner, J., & Haines, S. T. (2013). Best practice strategies for effective use of questions as a teaching tool. American Journal of Pharmaceutical Education, 77(7), 155.
Young, C. (2019). Increased frequency and planning: A more effective approach to guided reading in Grade 2. The Journal of Educational Research, 112(1), 121-130.



.jpeg)




It is a very well written blog. Excellent, Shiwei.
ReplyDeletePerfect to me.
5R reflected.
Marked
Best wishes
Lina